The Philosophy of Secession
This won't make it into anyone's "light reading" list, but it's worth noting as yet another signpost of the new world we're in. The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy doesn't add new categories unless the need is overwhelming, and, as this introduction makes clear, the topic of secession as a philosophical theory has attained its own sense of urgency. We couldn't agree more.
Until quite recently secession has been a neglected topic among philosophers. Two factors may explain why philosophers have now begun to turn their attention to secession. First, in the past decade there has been a great increase not only in the number of attempted secessions, but also in successful secessions, and philosophers may simply be reacting to this new reality, attempting to make normative sense of it. Second, in the same decade the idea that there is a strong case for some form of self-government for groups presently contained within states has gained ground. Once one begins to take seriously the case for special group rights for minorities — especially if these include rights of self-government — it is difficult to avoid the question of whether some such groups may be entitled to full independence.

4 Comments:
The right of self-determination is an unalienable right. It is thus granted by God and abrogated by no man. The right of self-determination, once understood, becomes an autonomic function.
Whereas I breathe and don't think about it, take away my breath and I'll fight to get it back.
We're given the illusion of freedom in this country, so we don't think too much about it. But, he who is NOT willing to sacrifice liberty for security must withdraw his consent to be governed by another. Withdrawal of consent, written in ink, is secession. Secession, written in blood, is liberty.
freebird,
And a lot of folks will get angry with you if you point out that their "freedom" is just an illusion. People don't like to hear they've been fooled, and especially don't want to admit how much they've enjoyed the illusion.
There is an LS pamphlet about the history of secession. What are some more recent examples? There's the breakup of Chechelslovakia, USSR, several african nations...
Free Acres:
Here's a quick list off the top of my head since 1990:
Czechoslovakia: Czech and Slovak Republics.
Yugoslavia: Serbia, Slovenia, Croatia, Bosnia & Herzegovina, Macedonia, Montenegro, and Kosova.
USSR: Russia, Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania, Moldova, Belarus, Ukraine, Kazakhstan, Uzbekistan, Kyrgyzstan, Turkmenistan, Tadjikistan, Georgia, Armenia, Azerbaijan.
Indonesia: Indonesia, East Timor.
Somalia: Somali and Somaliland (but Somaliland is not widely recognized).
Ethiopia: Ethiopia and Eritrea.
Buns in the oven (some of them):
Ukraine: Trans-Dniester Republic
Azerbaijan: Nagorno-Karabakh
Georgia: Abkhazia, South Ossetia
Serbia: Vojvodina
United Kingdom: Scotland
Spain: Catalonia and the Basque country
Italy into north and south (at least).
Canada: Québec
Bolivia into east and west
Russia: Chechnya, possibly others
Sudan: Darfur and/or a Christian nation in the south
The list can be greatly lengthened, depending on your opinion of the maturity of various secessionist movements.
Harold
Post a Comment
<< Home